You stand in the store with a smile on your face while your three-year-old hands the clerk his money and whispers a memorized "thank you."
It seems like the perfect moment of parental pride.
And 15 years later, your teenager throws a "thank you" over his shoulder without even looking you in the eye. A paradox? No. You just confused politeness with automatism.
Some phrases that we consider correct cripple children's psyche. And yes, "thank you" is one of them.
You turn gratitude into a ritual, depriving it of meaning. The child does not feel gratitude - he follows the command.
Instead, ask later: "Did you like the toy you got? How will you show it?" Let him find a way - with a smile, a hug, a drawing.
Forced "forgive" teaches hypocrisy. The guilty child gets angry, the "victim" feels false.
Try another way: "You upset Sasha. How can we fix it?" Perhaps he will offer to lend his car or help build a castle. This is real remorse.
It seems like support. In reality, it is a perfectionist attitude. After a failure, the child will decide: "I am not the smartest, so I am nobody." Better: "I see you tried very hard!" The emphasis is on the effort, not the result.
Children copy not words, but sincerity. Replace templates with real emotions.